1964-John Huarte (QB)_Notre Dame
1963-Roger Staubach (QB)_Navy
1962-Terry Baker (QB)_Oregon State
1961-Ernie Davis (RB)_Syracuse
1960-Joe Bellino (RB)_Navy
1959-Billy Cannon (RB)_LSU
1958-Pete Dawkins (RB)_Army West Point
1957-John David Crow (RB)_Texas A&M