1996-Danny Wuerffell (QB)_Florida
1995-Eddie George (RB)_Ohio State
1994-Rashaan Salaam (RB)_Colorado
1993-Charlie Ward (QB)_Florida State
1992-Gino Torretta (QB)_Miami
1991-Desmond Howard (WR)_Michigan
1990-Ty Detmer (QB)_BYU
1989-Andre Ware (QB)_Houston