1943-Angelo Bertelli (QB)_Notre Dame
1942-Frank Sinkwich (RB)_Georgia
1941-Bruce Smith (RB)_Minnesota
1940-Tom Harmon (RB)_Michigan
1939-Nile Kinnick (RB)_Iowa
1938-Davey O'Brien (QB)_TCU
1937-Clinton Frank (HB)_Yale
1936-Larry Kelley (TE)_Yale
